Vicario's Pizza & Pasta

Located in the heart of Bellefontaine, Ohio, Vicario's Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit destination for anyone craving authentic, hearty Italian-American comfort food. Specializing in pizza and pasta, this vibrant local gem serves up an impressive menu that offers something for all tastes, from classic pepperoni pizzas to inventive specialty pies bursting with bold flavors. 

Step inside Vicario's, and you’ll immediately notice the warm, welcoming atmosphere—casual yet lively, perfect for a relaxed meal with family or friends. The aroma of freshly baked dough mingling with savory tomato sauce invites you to dig into a slice of their famous pizza buffet, a popular choice for those who want to sample a variety of toppings. From the perfectly balanced “All The Way” pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and banana peppers, to the sweet and smoky Hawaiian topped with ham, pineapple, and bacon, there’s a delicious pie for every craving.

Not a pizza lover? Vicario’s pasta selections, including their classic spaghetti and savory Stromboli stuffed with provolone and mozzarella, offer a satisfying alternative. The Stromboli is particularly noteworthy as you can customize it with your choice of toppings, served with a rich side of marinara that’s perfect for dipping. Appetizers like breaded mushrooms or crispy chicken tenders paired with mouthwatering wing sauces bring an added layer of indulgence to your meal.

One of the standout features is their Wing Wednesday special, featuring both traditional and boneless wings tossed in flavorful rubs that strike the perfect balance between spicy and savory. And the thoughtfully crafted specialty pizzas—like the tangy Buffalo Chicken with hot sauce and diced chicken, or the comforting Meatball Pizza layered in marinara and cheese—show the kitchen’s commitment to quality and innovation.

Vicario’s doesn’t just serve food; it serves memorable experiences. Guests like Angie Ferdinand rave about the perfectly cooked pizzas that “were so good we will definitely be back,” while Brett Bender praises the “great sauce (Traditional), and lots of cheese,” highlighting the care put into every slice. The friendly staff and sizeable portions deliver excellent value, as noted by Kim Romine, who appreciated both the taste and generous servings during her stay in the area.

The combination of fresh ingredients, thoughtfully balanced flavors, and a genuine neighborhood vibe make Vicario's Pizza & Pasta a standout choice for Bellefontaine locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re craving a quick meal to go or a comforting dine-in experience, Vicario's offers an authentic taste that leaves you satisfied and eager to return.